EOI Points CalculatorEOI Points 8558 Stay Calculator8558 Days Portal

Australia’s One Nation proposes abolishing parent migration and cutting the refugee allocation by 90%

Key points

What has One Nation proposed for Australian parent migration and refugee allocations?

One Nation says that, if elected, it would completely abolish parent migration, retaining only 12-month visitor visas for parents and the Subclass 870 long-term parent visa. It would also cut the annual refugee allocation from 20,000 to 2,000, a 90% reduction.

I'm Kirk. If you would like to plan your studies or migration to Australia, you can add me on WeChat: NewstarsMel03.

After announcing in September that it would cut temporary visas by as many as 750,000 if elected, One Nation today announced new policy proposals targeting permanent migration, this time focusing on parent migration and refugees. One Nation leader Hanson said that, if elected, the party would cut the refugee allocation by 90% (from 20,000 to 2,000 a year) and completely abolish parent migration, retaining only 12-month visitor visas for parents and the Subclass 870 long-term parent visa.

Pauline Hanson proposes abolishing permanent parent visas and cutting the annual refugee allocation
Caption: Pauline Hanson announces policy proposals to abolish permanent parent visas and reduce the annual refugee allocation from 20,000 to 2,000.

The rationale behind the proposals

The rationale for abolishing parent migration is that each parent migrant would represent a budget saving of $515,000, while each refugee would represent a saving of $523,000. Neither figure has undergone rigorous scrutiny by the Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO); they are based solely on earlier Treasury estimates.

One Nation cites Treasury estimates comparing the fiscal contributions of parent migrants, refugees and skilled migrants
Caption: One Nation proposes abolishing permanent visas for parents and grandparents, citing Treasury estimates of around A$1.4 billion in savings for taxpayers and comparing the fiscal contributions of parent migrants, refugees and skilled migrants.

Hanson said Australia was still a generous country, but that Australians must be looked after first. She said parent migration placed a significant burden on Australia’s finances, particularly spending on healthcare, aged care and pensions, because parents arrived later in life and often had made little tax contribution to Australia.

Hanson cites Treasury modelling of the net costs of parent migration and refugee arrivals
Caption: Hanson releases migration policy cost estimates, citing Treasury modelling that permanent parent migration and refugee arrivals generate relatively high net costs, and advocates shifting the burden onto Australian taxpayers.

The electoral outlook: how likely are these proposals to be implemented?

Compared with other OECD countries, Australia has so far been relatively welcoming to refugees and parent migrants, alongside Canada. Canada has also recently paused new parent migration applications. Although One Nation’s support has continued to rise in a number of polls, the next federal election is still some way off (at least a year and a half). The party has also continued to face problems with candidates and internal financial disarray ahead of the imminent Victorian election. Earlier polls suggested it might govern with the Coalition, or even have a small chance of forming government alone. More recently, however, it has become fairly clear that, if the Liberal Party defeats Labor, it is likely to govern with an outright majority.

Over the past few months, the government has sharply reduced temporary visas and continued to impose restrictions on Subclass 485 and student visas, among others. NOM figures are clearly continuing to fall towards the target, although internal policy disagreements have prompted a number of reversals, such as the backflip on reducing refugee and working holiday visas. By raising a new migration issue now, One Nation also hopes to draw attention back to this subject.

Hanson shifts from proposed temporary visa cuts to proposals tightening permanent migration
Caption: After proposing a reduction of 750,000 temporary visas in September, One Nation’s Hanson turns to tightening permanent migration, advocating a migration stance that prioritises local Australian residents while the party faces management controversies.

The practical impact on parent migration applicants

For those who have already lodged an application and are in the queue, there should be no need to worry for now. All past experience we can refer to, including earlier reforms in New Zealand and Canada, suggests that lodged parent migration applications will continue to be assessed, rather than all being closed and returned outright. Requests for further information for Subclass 143 have been moving quickly recently, reaching applications from around 20 January 2019. For those who have not yet applied, we still suggest considering lodging early to join the queue, whether for Subclass 103 or 143. Joining the queue only requires payment of the first instalment of the visa application charge.

Questions and answers

What fees must be paid upfront to lodge a Subclass 103 or 143 parent migration application and join the queue?

Joining the queue only requires payment of the first instalment of the visa application charge.

Related Articles

Questions About Your Visa Situation?

Get in touch for a free consultation — we'll help you analyse your situation from every angle.

Book Consultation