[Tasmania vs South Australia] TAS State Nomination Reform Is Coming — Caught In Between? Here’s a Fresh Approach! Start Preparing Now Instead of Waiting!



Last week, the Tasmanian Government released a draft proposal for the new financial year’s state nomination requirements(draft only — not the final version), aimed at refining the state nomination selection process, improving efficiency, and providing more opportunities to applicants who genuinely align with Tasmania’s interests. For the full draft details, see:[Tasmania State Nomination May Undergo Major Changes in the New Financial Year — Feedback Welcome] Long-term residents may qualify for Subclass 190, work pathways broadened! System improvements to enhance invitation certainty!


The author considers the key terms to be

“pathway”

 “skilled”

 “international education”

 “settlement”


The reason the author has highlighted these key terms is an analysis of the state government’s detailed description of several potential pathways, combined with a comparison against the Tas 21–22 financial year requirements, as well asa comparison against South Australia’s state nomination requirements, which follow a very similar model. The author will now analyse each of the above key terms.


In short,comparing Tasmania’s potential new financial year reforms with South Australia’s state nomination, here are somesuggestions and fresh perspectives.


Key terms

Skilled

Firstly, Tasmania’s existing requirements framework, from areview perspective, is relatively subjective, primarily favouring local graduates while also constraining their field of study (491).For those from outside Tasmania seeking state nomination, if they do not convert to local graduate status, they essentially need either full-time employment or to meet the TSOL list requirements. This approach is not only unattractive and fails to bring in enough TSOL workers, but it also drives applicants to blindly pursue local graduate status while overlooking the fundamental objective — that the state government needs skilled individuals. With large numbers of graduates working in insufficiently skilled roles, combined with imprecise state nomination requirements, assessors can only subjectively evaluate local graduates’ profiles based on the submission window.Applicants with genuinely skilled employment are often unable to receive a timely nomination as a result, and end up spending unnecessary money on unnecessary courses.


So what does Tasmania consider to be skilled?

According to the new proposal,skilled is defined in three ways: first, relevance to the occupation; second, relevance to the course of study; third, by ANZSCO definition — Skilled Level 1–3 / certain carers.This third point is broadly consistent with South Australia’s definition of skilled. It also reflects Tasmania’s recognition of carer occupations. Although local support-sector roles are in oversupply, Tasmania does not dismiss the skills of those in these roles, and applicants currently in such positions can take comfort.

Key terms

International education

As for local qualifications under “international education”,the Tasmanian Government also seeks graduates who can withstand scrutiny in the local market. Local graduates will no longer be eligible for work experience exemptions,and will instead need a certain amount of local work experience to access the corresponding pathway.


For example, local Diploma or above graduates will need three months of work experience, while trade certificate holders will need to secure relevant employment.


Key terms

Settlement

This also introduces the Tasmanian Government’s integrated screening of “settlement” and “skilled”as two key indicators.


The Tasmanian Government has not entirely abandoned lower-skilled local graduates,but instead wants applicants to demonstrate their ability to settle locally through long-term residency and accumulated lower-skilled work (such as waiter roles).Here, the proposal’s original text refers to “ANZSCO 4”. The author believes this has a different meaning from the Carer occupations mentioned above, and should be understood as referring to Skilled Level rather than occupational group. Otherwise, the situation would revert to the previous pattern of applicants crowding into individual support and childcare courses.This clearly aims to recognise the contribution of long-term residency to the state — we look forward to seeing the specific requirements.

State nomination in the new financial year — a broadly positive outlook

State nomination information sharing group

Add our customer service and note: State Nomination



SA

This Tasmania proposal shares a very similar approach to South Australia’s state nomination in the current financial year


● The structure is broadly as follows:

– Work experience required for state nomination, starting from 3 months

– Part-time work experience accepted for non-local graduates

– Relevance of work experience to nominated occupation — concept broadened

– Long-term residency pathway

– Recognition of carer occupations


↓↓↓

For a detailed look at the individual pathways, the author has included the chart below for comparison across both dimensions,interested readers are welcome to open, review, and save it, or add the author on WeChat to discuss!


In addition,South Australia differs from Tasmania in that(at least based on the current draft comparison),there are numerous policies offering work experience exemptions and interstate applications, and interested readers can also refer to the earlierSouth Australia Talent programmearticle:Full Guide to the South Australia Talent Programme → Accountants can obtain Subclass 190, interstate applicants can apply, and meeting the criteria gives you a very strong chance of receiving an invitation! This is too good to miss!


If your background aligns with the analysis in this article, you have not yet received an invitation this financial year, and you are preparing for next year, South Australia already has ready-made and well-defined pathways to choose from — but that does not mean“switching to South Australia”is the right move for everyone,depending on your individual circumstances, feel free to add the author on WeChat for a one-on-one personalised assessment.


If you are currentlyweighing up between Tasmania, South Australia, and other regional states,you are also welcome to discuss and start preparing with the author in advance!Especially for those looking to become regional graduates — please choose your course of study very carefully!



There are still many unknown details in the Tasmania proposal to be confirmed. Until the end of this month, feedback from all sectors will be gathered based on this framework. Newstars is also collecting input from everyone to provide consolidated feedback to the state government,and everyone is welcome to take no more than 30 seconds to scan the QR code and complete the survey:


Study abroad and migration insight videos

Previously recommended articles

Visa granted in just 2 months — the “green” pathway for accounting and other in-demand fields!

Long-term residents may qualify for Subclass 190 — work pathways broadened!

A quiet but powerful migration option! Meets most people’s combined migration and study-abroad needs!

Newstars Shenyang office officially established!

Migration information sharing and Q&A group

Step 1: Press and hold to add our customer service contact

Step 2: After adding, please



Attention!Please verifygenuineNewstars consultants!

Contact our customer service for study abroad and migration planning consultations

Sydney

Melbourne

Canberra

Brisbane

Adelaide

Hobart

Beijing

Guangzhou

Shenyang


Scan the QR code to follow the Newstars official account


In the official account, reply withany of the following numbers or keywords (not the comment section at the bottom of the article),to receive the most timely and professional migration updates!Reply [A] to view the index (including all knowledge points)!

Reply:0000 → View 11.16 policy update (Subclass 491 + skilled migration points)

Reply: 000 → Latest visa/citizenship processing waiting times

Reply: 001 → Latest Subclass 189 EOI official report

Reply: 002 → Subclass 189 Skilled Independent migration

Reply: 003 → Subclass 190 state nomination by state

Reply: 004 → Subclass 489 regional state nomination

Reply: 005 → Student entrepreneur and investor migration

Reply: 006 → Parent migration visa

Reply: 007 → Employer-sponsored visa

Reply: 008 → Subclass 485 visa

Reply: 009 → Partner migration / points

Reply: 010 → Work experience points

Reply: 011 → PY points

Reply: 012 → NAATI/CCL points

Reply: 013 → Regional area points

Reply: 014 → Visitor visa

Reply: 015 → Working holiday visa

Reply: 016 → TAFE study

Reply: 017 → Australian international students migrating to Canada

Reply: 018 → Subclass 407 Training visa

Reply: 019 → Subclass 408 Temporary Activity visa

Reply: 020 → New Zealand migration

How the Subclass 408 visa benefits can work for you!Click “original article link”for a full breakdown of the Subclass 408 visa!